HOA agreements are becoming more constraining and outdated as times change but the HOA's do not adapt to the times. Is it better to just eliminate HOAs or terminate memberships?

It’s This is a very relevant and increasingly common concern, especially as more people find themselves living in communities governed by Homeowners’ Associations (HOAs), or, as they are more commonly known in India, Resident Welfare Associations (RWAs) or Apartment Owners’ Associations. The question of whether it’s better to eliminate HOAs altogether or simply allow members to terminate their memberships is complex, both legally and practically.

Legal Position of HOAs/RWAs in India

In India, the legal framework for such associations is primarily governed by state-specific Apartment Ownership Acts (like the Maharashtra Apartment Ownership Act, 1970 or the Karnataka Apartment Ownership Act, 1972), the Societies Registration Act, 1860, or the Cooperative Societies Acts of various states. These laws provide for the formation, registration, and functioning of associations that manage common areas and enforce community rules.

When you purchase a flat or plot in a development governed by an RWA or similar body, you typically become a member by default, either by virtue of the sale agreement or by operation of the relevant statute. The association’s bye-laws, which are registered and binding, set out the rights and obligations of members—including payment of maintenance, adherence to community rules, and participation in governance.

Are HOA Rules Binding? Can You Opt Out?

The Supreme Court has consistently held that once you become a member of such an association, you are bound by its bye-laws and rules, provided they are not ultra vires (beyond the powers) of the parent Act or contrary to public policy. For example, in Zoroastrian Cooperative Housing Society Ltd. v. District Registrar, Cooperative Societies (Urban), (2005) 5 SCC 632, the Supreme Court (per Justice S.B. Sinha) held that the bye-laws of a society, once registered, have the force of contract among members, and courts will not interfere unless they are illegal or violate fundamental rights.

If you wish to terminate your membership, most statutes and bye-laws provide for resignation or cessation of membership, usually upon transfer of your property or by following a prescribed procedure. However, simply “opting out” while retaining ownership is generally not permitted, as the association’s purpose is to manage common property and enforce collective obligations. This is reinforced by provisions in the relevant Acts (see, for example, Section 16 of the Maharashtra Apartment Ownership Act, 1970), which make membership and compliance with bye-laws mandatory for all owners.

Can HOAs Be Dissolved or Eliminated?

Eliminating an HOA or RWA entirely is legally possible, but only through a formal process—usually requiring a supermajority of members to agree, settlement of all liabilities, and transfer of management of common areas (often to the local municipal authority). This is a rare and complicated process, as the association is the legal entity responsible for the upkeep and management of shared facilities.

The courts have recognized the importance of such bodies for the orderly management of communal living spaces. In DLF Universal Ltd. v. Appropriate Authority, (2011) 2 SCC 673, the Supreme Court emphasized the role of RWAs in protecting the interests of residents and managing common areas. Unless there is gross illegality or violation of statutory provisions, courts are reluctant to interfere with their existence or functioning.

What If the Rules Are Outdated or Unfair?

If the association’s rules are outdated or unduly restrictive, the best legal recourse is to seek amendment of the bye-laws through the procedure laid down in the relevant Act or bye-laws themselves. Most statutes require a special resolution (often two-thirds or three-fourths majority) to amend bye-laws. If the association refuses to adapt or acts arbitrarily, members can approach the Registrar of Societies or the Cooperative Court (depending on the registration), and in extreme cases, the civil courts or High Court under Article 226 of the Constitution for relief.

The courts have intervened where associations act beyond their powers or violate fundamental rights. For instance, in Asha John Divian v. State of Kerala, AIR 2015 Ker 1, the Kerala High Court held that RWAs cannot make rules that infringe upon the fundamental rights of residents, such as the right to practice one’s religion or profession (Articles 25 and 19(1)(g) of the Constitution).

Practical Implications and Advice

• Eliminating HOAs/RWAs is rarely practical: Without a collective body, maintenance of common areas, security, and dispute resolution become unmanageable.

• Terminating individual membership is not generally allowed: As long as you own property in the community, you are bound by the association’s rules.

• Best approach is reform from within: Mobilize like-minded residents, call for a general body meeting, and propose amendments to the bye-laws to make them more contemporary and fair.

• Legal remedies exist for egregious conduct: If the association acts illegally or unreasonably, you can approach the Registrar or the courts for redress.

In summary:
While the frustration with outdated or rigid HOA/RWA rules is understandable, Indian law generally does not permit individual owners to simply “opt out” of membership, nor is it easy to dissolve such associations. The most effective solution is to work within the system to update and reform the rules, using the statutory mechanisms provided. If the association acts beyond its powers or violates your rights, legal remedies are available, but outright elimination of HOAs is not a practical or legally straightforward solution.

If you have a specific issue with your association’s rules or conduct, I can advise you on the precise legal steps to challenge or amend them under the relevant state law.

++++++

Disclaimer: All opinions and views are personal.

Best wishes,

Advocate Rajeev K Jha

Expert Technical and Environmental Due Diligence Services | Technical & Environmental due diligence || Sarve Permits

—

Contacts

sarvadvisory@gmail.com

9911-66-1818

Address

Flat No: 50808, Tower-5, Nikoo Homes-1, Bhartiya City, Thanisandra Main Road, Bangalore-560064

Opening hours

Monday - Friday: 9:00 - 18:00

Saturday: 9:00 - 16:00

Sunday: Closed